This is purely one man’s opinion. We can all disagree with each other, but please be respectful and make this a healthy place for everyone to be. Enjoy and have a good time while you’re here.
*Apart from every World Title match in the entire history of the PPV, the interpromotional RAW vs. SmackDown matches from recent years are also included. ECW is also included, since it only appeared once.
1991
Hulk Hogan(c) vs. The Undertaker – WWF Championship *
1992
Bret Hart(c) vs. Shawn Michaels – WWF Championship ****1/4
1994
Bret Hart(c) vs. Bob Backlund – WWF Championship **3/4
1995
Diesel(c) vs. Bret Hart – WWF Championship ****1/4
1996
Shawn Michaels(c) vs. Sycho Sid – WWF Championship ***1/2
1997
Bret Hart(c) vs. Shawn Michaels – WWF Championship ***3/4
1998
The Rock vs. Mankind – vacant WWF Championship **3/4
1999
Triple H(c) vs. The Rock vs. Big Show – WWF Championship **1/2
2000
Kurt Angle(c) vs. The Undertaker – WWF Championship **3/4
2002
Brock Lesnar(c) vs. Big Show – WWE Championship **
Elimination Chamber: Triple H(c) vs. Shawn Michaels vs. Rob Van Dam vs. Booker T vs. Chris Jericho vs. Kane – World Heavyweight Championship ****
2003
Goldberg(c) vs. Triple H – World Heavyweight Championship **3/4
2004
JBL(c) vs. Booker T – WWE Championship **
2005
John Cena(c) vs. Kurt Angle – WWE Championship ***1/2
2006
King Booker(c) vs. Batista – World Heavyweight Championship **
2007
CM Punk(c) vs. John Morrison vs. The Miz – ECW Championship ***
Randy Orton(c) vs. Shawn Michaels – WWE Championship ****1/4
Hell in a Cell: Batista(c) vs. The Undertaker – World Heavyweight Championship ****1/4
2008
Triple H(c) vs. Vladimir Kozlov vs. Edge – WWE Championship 1/2*
Chris Jericho(c) vs. John Cena – World Heavyweight Championship **3/4
2009
The Undertaker(c) vs. Big Show vs. Chris Jericho – World Heavyweight Championship ***
John Cena(c) vs. Triple H vs. Shawn Michaels – WWE Championship ***1/2
2010
Kane(c) vs. Edge – World Heavyweight Championship 3/4*
Randy Orton(c) vs. Wade Barrett – WWE Championship **
2011
Mark Henry(c) vs. Big Show* – World Heavyweight Championship 1/2*
Alberto Del Rio(c) vs. CM Punk – WWE Championship ***1/2
2012
Big Show(c) vs. Sheamus* – World Heavyweight Championship *1/4
CM Punk(c) vs. John Cena vs. Ryback – WWE Championship ***
2013
John Cena(c) vs. Alberto Del Rio – World Heavyweight Championship **3/4
Randy Orton(c) vs. Big Show – WWE Championship *
2015
Roman Reigns vs. Dean Ambrose – vacant WWE World Heavyweight Championship **3/4
MITB cash-in: Roman Reigns(c) vs. Sheamus – WWE World Heavyweight Championship N/R (I do not rate cash-ins, unless they are proper matches ie: Sandow’s cash-in, RVD’s cash-in, etc.)
2017
AJ Styles (WWE Champion) vs. Brock Lesnar (Universal Champion) ****1/2
2018
Daniel Bryan (WWE Champion) vs. Brock Lesnar (Universal Champion) ****1/2
MY TOP 5 MATCHES:
5.
4.
3.
2.
1.
THE TOP FIVE WRESTLERS:
5. CM PUNK
1) Vs. John Morrison Vs. The Miz (2007) ECW Championship ***
2) Vs. Alberto Del Rio (2011) WWE Championship ***1/2
3) Vs. John Cena Vs. Ryback (2012) WWE Championship ***
Overall rating: 3,17 (3 matches)
4. CHRIS JERICHO
1) Elimination Chamber Match (2002) World Heavyweight Championship ****
2) Vs. John Cena (2008) World Heavyweight Championship **3/4
3) Vs. Undertaker Vs. Big Show (2009) World Heavyweight Championship ***
Overall rating: 3,25 (3 matches)
3. BROCK LESNAR
1) Vs. Big Show (2002) WWE Championship **
2) Vs. WWE Champion AJ Styles (2017) ****1/2
3) Vs. WWE Champion Daniel Bryan (2018) ****1/2
Overall rating: 3,67 (3 matches)
2. BRET HART
1) Vs. Shawn Michaels (1992) WWF Championship ****1/4
2) Vs. Bob Backlund (1994) WWF Championship **3/4
3) Vs. Diesel (1995) WWF Championship ****1/4
4) Vs. Shawn Michaels (1997) WWF Championship ***3/4
Overall rating: 3,75 (4 matches)
1. SHAWN MICHAELS
1) Vs. Bret Hart (1992) WWF Championship ****1/4
2) Vs. Sycho Sid (1996) WWF Championship ***1/2
3) Vs. Bret Hart (1997) WWF Championship ***3/4
4) Elimination Chamber (2002) World Heavyweight Championship ****
5) Vs. Randy Orton (2007) WWE Championship ****1/4
6) Vs. John Cena Vs. Triple H (2009) WWE Championship ***1/2
Overall rating: 3,88 (6 matches)
These were the results that I came up with in the end, with Shawn Michaels just barely beating Bret Hart by a 0,13 overall difference, though he did have two more title matches at this event throughout the years.
Brock Lesnar finds himself immediately behind the two legends, with two fantastic matches in recent years getting him closer and closer to the top spot. How will he do against Rey Mysterio this year?
Thank you for your time reading, I’ll see you next time!